Q: How do Muslims read this line of the President of the United States: “If there were not an Israel, we would have to invent one to make sure our interests were preserved”? As a Christian I would like to better understand how you view this. I have called your Mosque and did not get a response. I am also a college student. Please answer at your convenience. Thanks Lisa (Full name and university name omitted by this site for the privacy of the questioner)

A: Salutations and greeting:

With respect, I thank you for wanting to hear responses from the horses mouth. My aim is not to trample you, but to be a tame horse as well! I speak not as a Palestinian, but a member of the Islamic faith who is not an Arab. I speak as a South African residing in the USA.

This Biden statement is deeply troubling for anyone who values the well-being of humanity and reflects on its profound implications. We must realize, politicians and public servants have an obligation to their nationals, and nationals must realize that they cannot have blood on their hands for mere immediate economic security and everyday pleasures. This statement by Mr. Biden – our President – with tremendous respect, I say that it gives rise to several disconcerting points:

1. Promotion of the Dehumanization of Palestinians: Strengthens the notion in the existence of Israel as solely to serve the interests of other nations, supports the idea of disregarding the rights of humanity, and veto’s the aspirations of Palestinian people. It reduces Palestinian population to a negligible factor in the equation while also devaluing their lives.
2. Justifies Power Politics: It perpetuates a viewpoint that Israel’s existence primarily serves geopolitical interests rather than the well-being of its citizens or regional stability. This Biden comment appears to justify the use of Israel as a pawn in global power politics, potentially at the expense of its own population.
3. Minimizes Palestinian Struggles: By framing the creation of Israel in this manner, it marginalizes the historical and ongoing struggles of Palestinians who have faced displacement, conflict, ethnic cleansing and other human rights violations as articulated by the UN observers. It overlooks their quest for self-determination, justice and statehood.
4. Fosters Animosity and Resentment: Such a statement fuels resentment and anger among Palestinians and their supporters, as it reinforces the perception that their suffering and aspirations are secondary to the interests of external powers.
5. Promotes the Obstruction of Peace: It makes it more challenging to foster a conducive environment for peace negotiations. Peace can only be achieved when the rights and aspirations of all parties are recognized and mutually respected.

None of the aforementioned points should be misconstrued as a criticism of the President of the United States or the ‘democratic’ process. It is important to acknowledge that as a society, we learn and evolve from both – our positive actions and our errors. I am grateful for the privilege to openly express sentiments without feeling apprehensive about doing so. Furthermore, it is my hope that such open communication will cultivate a deeper sense of understanding among all.

I sincerely thank you for this inquiry, I can sense your need to learn. Instead of calling, please text me and let me call you back at your convenience. Or leave an email with phone details.

Warm Regards,

Muhammed

Allah Certainly Knows Best.