Q: I have a sense when viewing media posts, especially in the past few days amid the conflict, and also social media posts, that the Muslim world is rejoicing in the destruction of Jews and America. Yet, they all aspire to come and live in America. How would you, as a person of religion, answer this conundrum? If they are so bold against us, why come here?
A: Greetings:
It is easy to misinterpret your question as ignorance of the fact that the beauty of diversity is a cornerstone of this nation’s strength. Our country’s identity as a global powerhouse has been built upon the richness of ideas and the tapestry of cultures that have made it a beacon of creativity and innovation in the eyes of the world.
Furthermore, the assumption that Muslims are rejoicing at the suffering of Jews is a common but misleading perception. It conveniently overlooks a broader context where common people have long felt that their voices go unheard, particularly when they voice objections to their leadership or government’s actions. This frustration often results in unfair labels of radicalism or fundamentalism, sidelining the genuine issues at hand. What’s crucial here is to promote open and respectful dialogue and cultivate a willingness to comprehend the root causes behind people’s concerns.
When people perceive their voices as unheard, it becomes a source of profound frustration. This frustration isn’t unique to any particular group. African Americans, Chinese, Japanese, Latinos, and countless others have experienced the same feeling of being ignored on various issues, with solutions often amounting to mere band-aids. Each community has faced its share of challenges in getting their perspectives acknowledged and understood.
The Palestinian issue, due to its sheer magnitude, has resonated with many across the globe, regardless of their familiarity with historical events such as 1096, 1948, 1967, or even more recent occurrences like the 2014 events or the Sabra and Shatila massacre. People are joining this cause not necessarily because they possess an intimate understanding of the Palestinian struggle, but because they share a common experience: feeling voiceless in the face of injustice. This shared pain has brought people together to stand against what they perceive as unjust collective punishment.
It is important to note that the sense of collective punishment is not limited to the Palestinian issue; it has been occurring on a lesser scale within minority communities for a considerable period. The frustration of not being heard or recognized is a universal experience, resonating across cultures and borders. People are rallying behind such causes to seek justice and ensure that their voices are no longer stifled, regardless of whether they possess in-depth knowledge of every historical detail.
Additionally, when American taxpayers voice concerns about their nation’s foreign policies, they are sometimes met with accusations of being anti-American. However, it is essential to acknowledge that many individuals choose to live in the United States out of genuine appreciation for this country, contributing significantly to academia and the economy. It is crucial to recognize that the vast majority of Muslims are law-abiding citizens who actively seek to benefit humanity – guided by the obligation to ensure their resources are spent for the greater good.
Individuals questioning of unquestioning foreign financial support are sometimes unfairly labeled as anti-Semitic or anti-American. It is time to move beyond these labels and engage in meaningful discussions to address citizens’ concerns and viewpoints, rather than alienating them with labels. There is no need to fear; these individuals are not seeking to destroy buildings or harm people when opposing certain viewpoints of major corporations or governments. The goal should always be to advocate for common-sense solutions. It is essential to understand that leaders in the Muslim world need to support U.S. interests for their safety and security. You seem to be conflating two separate issues: the choice to come or even be in America and the expression of one’s opinions aimed at improving American safety and America’s local and global image.
Contrary to certain media portrayals, Muslims deeply care about America. Their concern is not based on hatred but on a desire to uphold the nation’s values globally – contributing to a safer, better world. Open dialogue and understanding can bridge gaps for a more just and peaceful world. Leadership’s role is to address wrongdoing with adaptable approaches, while always adhering to universally accepted humanitarian principles.
I thank you for your inquiry, at least you wanted to hear it form the horses mouth! This is something i appreciate.
Allah Certainly Knows Best.