Q: Please help us on this one. I am writing for a family of 25 and we would like you help us out, please! Some have started based on global sighting. Some on calculation, and some refused based on not seeing the moon nationally. Scientifically, it was impossible to see the moon. My brother is at cal tech and his professors also agree that sighting it with the naked eye was impossible.So what does our family and extended family do. Also, would you as the imaam fast monday or tuesday. JAK
A: I am assuming that none of you are fuqaha (Islamic jurists), so you have the following choices regarding the start of Ramadan:
- Follow your local Islamic center. If you feel this is an error, schedule a meeting with them after Ramadan. There’s no need to spoil your Ramadan. Go with your proof, you will have plenty to support you.
- If you are consistent with local moon sighting, then wait for your first fast to be on Tuesday. If this is your choice, do not feel guilty about it. Organizations like www.crescentwatch.org and chicagohilal.org are reputable and have major scholars on their rosters supporting your decision.
- If your center follows calculations, and you feel that this is the best choice, follow it. However, do seek repentance (make tawba) for not following the hadith that states to look for the moon to start Ramadan. (Cal tech appears to be correct on this one.)
- If you are a Musaleen (those who pray) at our Musjid, please ask your final question after Ramadan. I understand that many are in pain or even confused, and I do hnot want to downplay anyone’s sentiments or appear to add more salt to the fragile situation.
Allah Certainly Knows Best.